There’s something special about a really good cookie—the kind that’s buttery, freshly baked and just impossible to stop at one. Our Drop, Slice & Stuffed Cookies collection brings together Sugar Shack Bake Shoppe favourites, from classic chocolate chip and buttery shortbread to delicate thumbprints, pretty cookie press cookies, giant stuffed cookies, and other small-batch treats.

Whether you’re filling a cookie tray, bringing something sweet to a gathering, treating someone special, or simply stocking your own cookie jar, you’ll find plenty of delicious options to choose from. Our cookies are baked fresh in Ridgeway and proudly made for cookie lovers throughout the Niagara Region.

Pickup Details: Orders are typically ready within 2–3 business days. We’ll send you a notification as soon as your order is ready for pickup.